Trouble on Everest.
In 2013 a group of Western climbers and angry Sherpas allegedly got into a confrontation that made global headlines. This documentary explores the unequal relationship between cashed-up foreign expeditions and their guides, plus local tradition, as exemplified by Phurba Tashi Sherpa, an experienced climber.... More
Director Jennifer Peedom and her team set out to uncover the cause of this altercation, intending to film the 2014 climbing season from the Sherpas' point of view. Instead, they captured Everest's greatest tragedy, when a huge block of ice crashed down onto the climbing route, killing 16 Sherpas. For the Himalayan workers repeatedly traversing the mountain carrying supplies, the risk of this hazardous endeavor is multiplied.Hide
On Demand, DVD & Blu-Ray
Available from 4 providers
BY Steve Newall Flicks Writer
If being at the right place at the right time can make or break a particular breed of documentary, the odds of coming away with the goods have got to be better atop Mt Everest than damn near anywhere else. In the case of Sherpa, with its focus on the Himalayan people who shlep expeditions’ gear up the mountain and are reliant on the income this provides, this setting can only aid a film that likely would have proved revealing even without the drama that the peak provides.... More
The Sherpa people are typically in the background, if at all, in films about Everest such as re-enactment of Sir Edmund Hillary’s feats Beyond the Edge or Everest, Hollywood’s take on Rob Hall’s tragic demise. To see the home and family one Sherpa leaves behind lends valuable context to the risks taken on foreign climbers’ behalf, before the film joins him on a commercial expedition, one that sees tragedy and simmering tensions combine.
Director Jennifer Peedom has shot several previous Everest projects, and this experience aids both the film’s raw footage and the relationships drawn upon. If you’re in the mood for mountainous intrigue that’s not The Eiger Sanction, you could do worse than this, especially if over-familiar with globe-trotting Westerners indulging an appetite for thrills. Fear not, though, Sherpa has little desire in hammering any particular message home, beyond offering a window into a seldom-seen culture.Hide
The Peoples' Reviews
Your rating & reviewRate / Review this movie
Rate and/or review
BY cinemusefilm superstar
Australian filmmaker Jennifer Peedom starts out asking why the traditionally friendly Sherpa guides turned aggressive towards tourists in the 2013 climbing season. The widely reported brawl was triggered by a single swear word directed at a Sherpa, igniting tensions that were simmering since Hillary was Knighted for his 1953 ascent while Sherpa Tenzing received lesser credit. In the middle of filming the brawl story, a massive avalanche claimed 16 Sherpa lives. Suddenly it is about the politics of an ethnic group demanding respect, no longer prepared to risk lives for meagre wages from an industry hosting thousands of tourists each year and charging summit climbers $75,000 – $100,000 for the privilege. The camera becomes a witness to tragedy, then grief that turns to anger and political activism. Audiences become judge in a case involving ethnic discrimination and the commercial exploitation of people who have been used as cheap mules. It’s a complex dilemma with no easy solutions because the same commercial interests have done much to improve the lives of Sherpas.
The film shows political sensitivity in telling the story from the Sherpa viewpoint. Its great strengths lie in extraordinary cinematography and sound recording under the most chaotic high-altitude conditions a filmmaker can ever experience. The camera works skilfully across the visual pleasures of vast mountain-scapes to angry grief stricken Sherpa faces and frustrated tourist climbers, with a soundtrack of howling wind, crunching ice and hammering stakes that viscerally create a ‘being there’ feel. Peedom lets the story tell itself without manipulative editing, and it is highly engaging while being informative about a world that few of us will enter. It is beautifully filmed and teaches much about Sherpa life and their struggle for recognition.Hide
Showing 1 of 1 reviews. See all reviews